Jackdaw by KJ Charles Review
Eikna Score: 8.0/10. Recommended.
Jackdaw is KJ Charles at her most bruising: a second chance romance between an ex-policeman who went to prison because of his lover and the thief who put him there, and it refuses to let either of them off lightly. The opening is hard going and the ending ties up a little too neatly, but the long, grudging road to forgiveness in between is some of the most honest writing in her Magpies world.
Read it if you like second chance romance where the betrayal is real and the forgiveness has to be earned, or you finished the Charm of Magpies trilogy wanting more of that London. Skip it if a dubious consent scene in the opening chapter is a dealbreaker, or you want both heroes' points of view.
Jackdaw at a Glance
Jackdaw is a 2015 MM historical fantasy romance by KJ Charles, set in the world of her A Charm of Magpies trilogy after Flight of Magpies. Samhain first published it on February 17, 2015, and KJC Books reissued it in 2017. It follows Ben Spenser and Jonah Pastern, can be read on its own, and ends happily.
| Author | KJ Charles |
|---|---|
| Series | The World of A Charm of Magpies (set after Flight of Magpies; the author says it can stand alone) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, paranormal and historical (Victorian London) |
| Main tropes | Second chance, enemies to lovers, on the run, betrayal and forgiveness, cop and thief |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Dubious consent, homophobia, imprisonment, a brief suicidal thought (full list below) |
| POV | Single POV: Ben Spenser |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 203 (2017 KJC Books paperback); 189 in the original Samhain edition |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Cornell Collins (Audible, 2018) |
| First published | February 17, 2015 |
| Publisher | Samhain Publishing (original); KJC Books (current edition) |
What Is Jackdaw About?
Jackdaw starts after the worst has already happened. Ben Spenser was a police constable who spent six months in love with Jonah Pastern, a con artist and windwalker who can walk on air. Then Jonah betrayed him and ran, and Ben paid for it with his job, his reputation and a stretch of hard labour.
Now Ben is out, and he wants Jonah to pay. He finds him easily enough. The trouble is what happens next: Ben cannot stop wanting him, Jonah will not stop insisting he loves Ben, and within a few chapters the two of them are on the run together from the police, the magical justiciary and some people with far worse intentions. Somewhere along the way they have to decide whether there is anything left to save.
What Makes This Second Chance Romance Work
Jackdaw works as a second chance romance because the first chance ended in genuine harm. Jonah did not misunderstand Ben or fail to call. He did something that cost Ben nearly everything, and the book never pretends otherwise. That makes every step toward forgiveness feel heavy and real, and it is why Love Bytes' reviewer said the emotional stakes felt higher than in the trilogy: Ben and Jonah have almost nobody on their side.
The other hook is class and powerlessness. The Magpies trilogy has an earl at its centre. Jackdaw has a disgraced copper and a thief from the bottom of London, and when the magical authorities come after them, there is no title to hide behind. The Novel Approach called it a wonderfully written romance between two all-too-human young men, per the author's site, and that ordinariness is the point.
If you like second chance stories with real damage behind them, this one belongs near the top of the list.
My Review
I went into Jackdaw expecting a fun side trip from the Magpies trilogy and got something darker and more interesting. It is a short book about anger, and about whether love can survive somebody doing the unforgivable. It does not answer that question cheaply, at least until the final chapters.
Romance and Chemistry
The chemistry between Ben and Jonah is never in doubt, and that is the problem they both have. Ben wants revenge and keeps ending up in bed with the man he wants it from. All About Romance described the pairing as opposites attract with an enemies to lovers edge, and that is fair, though it undersells how much history is in the room.
The opening is the part every reader talks about. Ben tracks Jonah down, shackles him with an iron cuff that blocks his magic and hits him, and the sex that follows is, in All About Romance's words, a scene that rides the edge of consent. KJ Charles flags it plainly in her content notes. I found it painful to read, and I think it is meant to be. What follows is the slow work of the two men rebuilding something on equal terms, and by the end the romance had earned my belief, though I understand readers who could not get past chapter one.
The Characters
Ben is the only viewpoint, and he is a good one: proud, decent, stubborn and furious. Love Bytes praised the choice of Ben's point of view because it lets you see both Jonah's flaws and his good qualities through someone who knows them better than anyone. The cost is that Jonah stays partly opaque. All About Romance wanted his perspective and more of his backstory, and so did I. He is charming and slippery on the page, and some of his choices would have landed harder if we had seen them from the inside.
The secondary cast is strong. All About Romance singled out the vivid supporting characters, and readers of the trilogy will spot familiar faces among the people chasing the pair. Love Bytes listed Stephen Day among the pursuers, and seeing him from the outside, as an alarming and very powerful figure, is a treat if you have read the earlier books.
I also liked how Charles uses Jonah's magic. All About Romance pointed to the idea of a magical talent as a burden, and Jonah's windwalking is both his freedom and the thing that marks him as a target. It is one of the better pieces of world-building in the series.
Writing and Pacing
The prose is quick, clean and full of London: molly houses, rooftops and the view across the city from them. The pace is high once the chase starts, and at around 200 pages there is no slack. JL Gribble called it incredibly satisfying and dramatic, per the author's site, and the middle section, with the two men forced to rely on each other, is the best stretch.
The ending is where I part company slightly. After a book that makes you feel the cost of what Jonah did, the final chapters resolve things quickly. All About Romance called the ending a bit too happily wrapped up, and that matches my read. I was glad to see them happy. I would have liked them to work a little harder for it on the page.
Jackdaw is a raw, honest second chance romance that takes betrayal seriously and then lets its heroes off a little too easily at the end. Read it if you want angst with real stakes and you can handle a hard opening scene.
How Spicy Is Jackdaw?
Jackdaw is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The sex is explicit and frequent for a short book, and it is tied to the emotional story, which means the early scenes are angry and the later ones are tender. Romance.io readers rate the steam 4 out of 5.
Consent note: the first sex scene takes place while Jonah's magic is blocked by an iron cuff and after Ben has hit him, and KJ Charles herself labels it dubious consent. Later scenes are clearly mutual.
Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from KJ Charles's own notes and reader reports:
- An on-page scene of dubious consent
- Physical violence between the leads in the opening
- Homophobia, in the past and on the page
- Imprisonment and hard labour (past)
- Betrayal and pursuit by police
- A brief suicidal thought
- Explicit sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Jackdaw?
Jackdaw suits readers who want an angsty MM second chance romance with real betrayal, explicit heat and a magical Victorian London, and who are happy with one point of view. It is less suited to readers who need consent to be clear from the first scene, or who want a long book with both heroes' inner lives.
Best for:
- Fans of second chance romance with genuine harm to repair
- Readers who finished A Charm of Magpies and want more of that world
- Anyone who likes working-class heroes and on-the-run plots
- Readers who enjoy angst that ends happily
Not for:
- Readers for whom dubious consent is a hard limit
- Anyone who wants both heroes' points of view
- Readers who want a lighter, low-angst romance
- Readers looking for closed-door romance (try our closed door picks)
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Jackdaw was warmly received and was runner-up for Gay Fantasy Romance in the 2015 Rainbow Awards, according to the author. Love Bytes gave it five hearts and called it their favourite book in the series, and The Novel Approach gave it five stars.
Where they agree. The emotional weight. Reviewers praise how seriously the book treats Jonah's betrayal and how the two men have to work toward forgiveness. All About Romance strongly recommended it and admired the secondary characters; Love Bytes thought the stakes felt higher than in the trilogy.
Where they split. The opening and the ending. All About Romance found the first sex scene painful and wanted Jonah's point of view, and felt the ending was wrapped up too neatly. Some reader reviewers say they could not get past the coercive opening at all, while others think it is exactly what makes the reconciliation mean something.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Jackdaw scores 8.0 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its highest mark for emotional impact and lower marks for a single point of view and an ending that resolves faster than the rest of the book.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Fierce chemistry and a believable rebuild, per All About Romance; the opening scene costs it. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Ben is a strong lead; Jonah stays partly opaque, a point All About Romance raised. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Tight and quick at about 200 pages, with no slack once the chase starts. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4.5 | Love Bytes found the stakes higher than the trilogy; the betrayal really hurts. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers explicit heat tied to the emotional arc, with a clear consent warning. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A real HEA, but All About Romance found it too neatly wrapped. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4 | Rewards a reread once you know where Jonah is coming from. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Jackdaw is the darkest of the Magpies-world romances and a strong companion to the trilogy rather than a substitute for it, landing at a final Eikna Score of 8.0/10.
Is Jackdaw a Standalone?
Jackdaw can be read as a standalone, and KJ Charles says so herself, but it is set after the A Charm of Magpies trilogy and you will get more from it, and avoid a few spoilers, if you read the trilogy first. Love Bytes recommends reading Flight of Magpies before it.
- Book 1: The Magpie Lord (2013): Lucien Vaudrey, Lord Crane, and Stephen Day
- Book 2: A Case of Possession (2013): Crane and Stephen
- Book 3: Flight of Magpies: Crane and Stephen
- Same world: Jackdaw (2015): Ben Spenser and Jonah Pastern, set after Flight of Magpies
- Same world: A Queer Trade (2016, novella), then Rag and Bone (2017)
Best place to start: The Magpie Lord. Best format: print or ebook for the tight single point of view; Cornell Collins also narrates the trilogy, so the audiobook keeps the voices consistent across the series. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved Jackdaw, Read These Next
If you loved Jackdaw, look for MM romances with real history between the leads, magic or menace in the background, and forgiveness that has to be earned.
- The Magpie Lord by KJ Charles: the start of the trilogy behind Jackdaw, with an exiled earl and a furious magician.
- The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal by KJ Charles: a Victorian ghost-hunter romance told across twenty years of cases.
- Spectred Isle by KJ Charles: two damaged men and a lot of very old magic in 1920s London.
- After Felix by Lily Morton: a contemporary second chance where the man who did the damage has to work for forgiveness.
- Captive Prince by C.S. Pacat: enemies to lovers with a brutal opening and a slow, hard-won trust.
Frequently Asked Questions
Jackdaw prompts the same questions from most readers: whether it stands alone, how spicy it is, what the consent warning means and how it ends. Short answers below.
Is Jackdaw a standalone?
Mostly. KJ Charles says Jackdaw can be read on its own, but it is set after the A Charm of Magpies trilogy and reads best after Flight of Magpies.
Is Jackdaw spicy?
Yes. Jackdaw is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit scenes for a short book.
Does Jackdaw have dubious consent?
Yes. The author flags one on-page scene of dubious consent early in the book, when Jonah's magic is blocked and the two men are still enemies.
Does Jackdaw have a happy ending?
Yes. Ben and Jonah get a happily ever after, though some reviewers felt it arrives a little too neatly.
Who narrates the Jackdaw audiobook?
Cornell Collins narrates the Jackdaw audiobook, as he does the A Charm of Magpies trilogy.
Whose point of view is Jackdaw told from?
Jackdaw is told entirely from Ben Spenser's point of view.
The Bottom Line
Jackdaw earns a 8.0/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want an angsty, explicit MM second chance romance in which the betrayal is real, the forgiveness is slow and the setting is KJ Charles's magical Victorian London. The reason to pick it up is Ben: a good man with every right to be angry, learning what he is willing to forgive.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Jackdaw, KJ Charles (author site: blurb, content notes, narrator, award, review quotes)
- Jackdaw by KJ Charles, All About Romance
- Release day review: Jackdaw, Love Bytes
- Review: Jackdaw, The Novel Approach
- Jackdaw, Romance.io (steam rating and tags)
- Jackdaw audiobook, Audible
- A Charm of Magpies series, Audible
- A Charm of Magpies series list, Fantastic Fiction
- Jackdaw, KJC Books paperback listing, MIT Press Bookstore
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.